A Work of Art … in a Science
lesson?!
It was Open Evening at Newton Academy, a
school known for the quality of its science teaching. Prospective parents with
their children were being taken on tours of the school. Volunteer pupils from
Year 7 had come in after school to work with their teachers on demonstration
lessons for the benefit of the visitors.
Dr Dawkins Crick-Watson and his wife, Indira,
were visiting the school’s science rooms with Melanie, their daughter. Melanie
(‘Mel’ to her friends but most definitely ‘Melanie’ to her parents!) had
announced to all at the age of four years and two months that she wanted to be a
SCIENTIST when she was ‘growed up’ and that conviction had not left her from
that day to this. She was excited - could it be that she would soon be a pupil
at Newton Academy?!
They entered the first science room.
‘When you’ve seen one science lab, you’ve
seen them all’, grumbled Dad C-W,
impatient to get on. Some pupils were gathered around a computer with their
teacher. All eyes were on the screen. Dad moved towards the door: the
Headteacher had gone on ‘far, far too long’ in his welcoming speech. ‘Wait,
Dad’, said Mum and Mel in unison,
‘Come and see this!’ On the screen was a painting by the eighteenth
century artist, Joseph Wright of Derby, which showed an experiment on a bird in
an air pump. A pupil was clicking to zoom in so that they could all see the
details more clearly. The group of people in the picture looked on as the
scientist operated a pump to suck the air out of the glass bowl which contained
the bird. They displayed differing reactions to what is happening, as did the
pupils looking at the picture. The teacher asked them, "Is it wrong for a
scientist to have this much power? Is he playing God? Does that matter?" An
animated discussion broke out among the pupils. Mel listened with her Mum and
Dad and they found themselves imagining what it would be like if they were in
the room in the picture, watching the scientist … and the little bird.
After some minutes, Dad drew away.
"Come on", he said, "We have more
to see". And he muttered, "Science was never like this in my day!",
as they moved into the next lab. "Ah, this is more like it!’, exclaimed
Dad. Pupils were tending plants in large jars, others were cleaning and
recycling water, and others were checking solar cells producing electricity. A
number were studying worksheets entitled ‘DIY Earth’ which showed a picture and
diagram of Biosphere 2. As Mum, Dad and Mel looked over the shoulders of a
couple of the pupils, the worksheet text told them that Biosphere 2 was a large
structure set up in the Arizona Desert to try to produce a miniature copy of the
earth (Biosphere1). One of the tasks set required the pupils to think of three
items in their homes that use energy and to describe how they take in energy and
change it into another type of energy. "Now this is what I call science!"
said Dad with evident approval. That lasted until he noticed that the pupils at
the next desk had moved on to a different task which read, "Biosphere 2
needed various rules in order to help to establish the community living there.
What rules would you make if you were in charge? Give reasons for them." Dad
moved again towards the door, Mum and Mel lingered in thought.
One lab to go. What were the pupils
doing here? It seemed more like mathematics than science! They were working on
the sequence of numbers which begins 1, 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13, 21, 34, …, a sequence
which was apparently discovered by Leonardo Fibonacci in Pisa in the thirteenth
century. The pupils were looking closely at a picture of a sunflower seedhead
and carefully counting the number of clockwise and anti-clockwise spirals in the
patterns formed by the seeds. The quicker ones had discovered that the numbers
of spirals were two adjacent numbers in Fibonacci’s sequence. Mel looked at a
worksheet on the top of a set on the teacher’s desk. She drew her parents’
attention to how it said that Fibonacci numbers occurred very frequently in the
natural world and how it went on to ask about the number of wings on a fly, legs
on an octopus, seeds in an apple, arms on a starfish, … "I wonder why that
is", said Mel. "It makes you think", said her Mum.
What was the world coming to? Dad was ill at ease and anxious to go. Art in a
science lesson? Ethical issues? Spiritual questions? Open-ended discussion?
Pauses for reflection? It was never like that in Dad’s day. We stuck to the
facts, the evidences and proofs. "Never like this in my day!", muttered
Dad again as they left the science block. "What a pity it wasn’t!", said
Mel and her Mum in heartfelt unison.
"If this is science", thought Mel as she fastened her seat belt in the back
of the car, "then I DO want to be a
scientist! I do! I do!".
John Shortt |

|
John Shortt is a freelance education
consultant and Travelling Secretary for the European Educators’ Christian
Association (EurECA). He was formerly Head of Research & Development at
the Stapleford Centre and Director of the Charis Project and before that
he taught secondary Maths for seventeen years. The examples in this
article are taken from Charis Science Units A1 - A9.The Charis Science
publications (written to provide materials for the promotion of spiritual
and moral development) are available from:
The Stapleford Centre,
The Old Lace Mill, Frederick Road,
Stapleford,
Nottingham NG9 8FN
Tel: 0115 939 6270 |
|